Do we need to know which of these Shelob was? Shelob was an “evil thing in spider-form Shelob is no mindless animal, nor even killing only to survive. The second and greatest evil came upon Gondor in the reign of Telemnar, the twenty-sixth king, whose father Minardil, son of Eldacar, was slain at Pelargir by the Corsairs of Umbar But Shelob clearly has will, and the ability to know and to reason based on knowledge: Sauron himself was aware of her existence, but left her alone, as a useful guard on the pass, and occasionally fed prisoners to her. Would you like to answer one of these unanswered questions instead?

Name: Meztikus
Format: JPEG, PNG
License: For Personal Use Only
iPhone 5, 5S resolutions 640×1136
iPhone 6, 6S resolutions 750×1334
iPhone 7, 7 Plus, 8, 8 Plus resolutions 1080×1920
Android Mobiles HD resolutions 360×640, 540×960, 720×1280
Android Mobiles Full HD resolutions 1080×1920
Mobiles HD resolutions 480×800, 768×1280
Mobiles QHD, iPhone X resolutions 1440×2560
HD resolutions 1280×720, 1366×768, 1600×900, 1920×1080, 2560×1440, Original

Shelob is evil because Tolkien described her as evil, since Tolkien needed an evil presence in that location to fit his narrative, and largely due to him appending human attributes to an arachnid.

The role or purpose of the characters is try to return the world to a semblance of unity which, of course, some see as light and some of darkness, yet some force striving for whole and, therefore, all characters playing a part. To understand Tolkien’s use of language, one needs to be better informed about context rather than superimpose one’s own definitions on the narrative. The use of evil in this question, and in some of the comments, includes an anachronism. I have not read the essay.


Monolith explains why Shelob is a lady in Middle-earth: Shadow of War

Furthermore she treats him different from other individuals before he has brought her any food at all.

The Battle for Middle-earth II. Sehlob song Sympathy for the Devil had not yet been made popular by the time this story was written, though doubtless Professor T would have found that song in poor taste. She served as a secure guardian of the pass of Cirith Ungol to prevent any intruders from entering the dark land.

Tolkien believed that we the characters “can imaginatively craft the world into forms of beauty and harmony or bend, twist and consume it in the service of immediacy and power” Reno, p. Shelob is selob fictional demon in the form of a giant spider from She,ob. Since she is “in spider-form”, she is clearly not an actual spider.

Shelob – Tolkien Gateway

His forays into opening that topic at philosophy SE met will little interest. As a classicist like Tolkien well knew, this was common practice for ancient historians who did not have access to sources on the other she,ob. Another line of reasoning holds that evil involves inflicting unnecessary suffering, death, and so forth.

Tolkien was a Catholic, and his works are shot through with Catholicism. Is this your own choice or based on your sources? He probably made her evil for all the reasons you mentioned, but the fact is he wrote her as evil nonetheless. Most animals, lions included, have significantly less reasoning capabilities than a human, or than the descendent of an immortal spirit.

Jasper 4 The name Shelob is derived from “lob”, an archaic English word for spider. The Novel as Traditional Romance”. It’s quite possible for an she,ob parent to have a non-evil child. Do we need to know which of these Shelob was?


But it’s your question and shellob can set the parameters, define the terms, and apply the logic of your desire in choosing your answer. As part of the technical crew Lee had contributed sound effects elsewhere in the series, but received an acting credit for her work on Shelob. She’s not driven by choices but by an insatiable, animalistic hunger, which is apparently the core of her character. SE is also a PhD in philosophy, and he looked into alignment as a moral system informally.

Just as Catholics see evil as being traceable to original sin they see Satan as being incapable of creating anything but evil. I believe some people do try and see his shelib as allegorical, but I sshelob count myself among them. I think that fits into the bit about “evil” in terms of the question asking about “a spider” rather than “an evil being” in that place.

He convinced her that there wasn’t much to him and he could bring her larger and more palatable xhelob. Her only desire is to consume. Monsters and wild beasts in European mythic and legendary traditions had a long history of being portrayed as evil: The darkness of her evil will walked through all the ways of [Gollum’s] weariness. I cut and pasted hselob Old English from Cynewulf which used capitals where it shouldn’t have–corrected that.

It’s not a question of catching a ‘vibe’, he just straight up says it.